BRONZE SHOE AWARD WINNERS
| 1967 | Graig King | 1999 | Jessie Hawkins | |
| 1968 | Larry Reynosa | 1999 | John Hill | |
| 1969 | David Smith | 2000 | Cory Sandefur | |
| 1970 | Chuck Desautelle | 2001 | Justin Haney | |
| 1971 | Bill Bryant | 2001 | Nick Kaiser | |
| 1972 | Jeff Rains | 2002 | Pat Loughman | |
| 1973 | Jeff Rains | 2003 | Micah Reed | |
| 1974 | Winkie Ward | 2004 | Will Strong | |
| 1975 | Mike Jenkins | 2005 | Casey Catlett | |
| 1976 | Lonny Gibson | 2006 | Dan O’Brien | |
| 1977 | Rod Rains | 2007 | Damian Kaiser | |
| 1978 | Brent Smotherman | 2007 | Chris Gibson | |
| 1979 | Joe Ferguson | 2008 | Phil Long | |
| 1980 | Mark Sanders | 2009 | Skyler Logsdon | |
| 1981 | Tyson Hardman | 2009 | Evan Hardman | |
| 1982 | Carl Woolwine | 2010 | Tony Johnson | |
| 1983 | Fred Dougles | 2011 | Andy Drifka | |
| 1984 | Tim Jeffris | 2012 | Brad Sloan | |
| 1985 | Vince Burrell | 2013 | Allen Rogers | |
| 1986 | Todd Cowgill | 2014 | Atticus Reyes | |
| 1987 | Mike Salka | 2014 | Austin Baker | |
| 1988 | Brian Baldwin | 2015 | Regin Wilson | |
| 1989 | Trever Mathewson | 2016 | Brayden Rogers | |
| 1990 | John Trent | 2017 | Devon Page | |
| 1991 | Nacho Vega | 2018 | Braydon Rogers and Danial McGrew | |
| 1991 | Matt Johnson | 2019 | Chandler Pullen | |
| 1992 | Steve Saum | 2020 | ||
| 1993 | Ben Churchill | 2021 | Isaac Ruiz | |
| 1994 | Josh Hawkins | 2022 | Colton Roddick | |
| 1995 | Rusty Perry | 2023 | Sol McGarey | |
| 1996 | Russell Farrar | 2024 | Uriel Covarrubias | |
| 1997 | Andrew Merritt | 2025 | Elliot Sheets | |
| 1998 | Brandon Titus | 2026 |